Cagle: “The first [Cagle.com] Virginia Tech cartoons were terrible”

Daryl Cagle, the man behind the syndicate that bears his name, spoke out on his blog about the awful batch of “predictable” cartoons responding to the tragedy. He specifically mentions the abundance of cartoons including “…Uncle Sam or the Virginia Tech mascot, with bowed heads…” and “…lots of riffs on the school logo…”

He half-heartedly apologizes for the crew, suggesting that the time-crunch brought on by their daily deadlines is to blame. I’d distance myself from some of those cartoons too, but seriously – he’s the one who hires these guys, and he sells them to daily newspapers who are full of other people who have daily deadlines. And it’s not like many of these cartoonists don’t crank out the same batch of predictable and interchangeable cartoons on every topic.

Call and response – Apr 17, 2007

from the Omaha Reader

I think this is the first time I’ve ever done a cartoon in response to a cartoon, but after discussing Jeff Koterba’s cartoon in today’s Omaha World Herald with several friends in and out of the media, I had to do it.

One thing about tragedies like this that angers me is how much easier it is for politicians and public figures to go through the motions of sympathizing than it is to actually take a stand. Koterba’s cartoon expresses that perfectly…only without any cynicism or irony. It is simply the visual embodiment of that political shallowness and social uselessness.

virginia tech school shootings guns weapons

My idea to save editorial cartooning

One might be surprised that a lowly freelance editorial cartoonist could come up with a plan to save an entire industry, but I have done it.

I was inspired by all the recent discussion surrounding the death of B.C. and Wizard of Id creator Johnny Hart. Hart had wished that, after his death, his children and grandchildren continue the strips he had created. This has caused controversy in the cartooning world, as comic page space is highly valued real estate, and for every legacy strip like Peanuts or B.C. that continues on after the creator’s death there will be one fewer new strip exposed to audiences.

It’s a reasonable case to make, as some folks claim that syndicates and newspapers are sacrificing the future of their business for the short-term gain of pleasing long-time fans. Meanwhile, hard-working new cartoonists are denied access to readers so that the syndicates can make a safe buck.

So thinking about that – about an industry voluntarily making a decision to promote long-term growth at the expense of short-term bottom lines, I got to thinking about my own field of editorial cartooning. In my eight years at doing this, I’ve found that whether you’re listening to a cartoonist on a panel or reading a journal article by one of them, there are only two truths they’ll speak about the state of the industry:

1. Editorial cartooning is a dying field, as newspapers continue to lay off their staff cartoonists in favor of cheap syndicated cartoons. The numbers of professional cartoons are dwindling as more and more laid-off cartoonists have to turn to syndication to make their living.

2. Don’t even bother trying to get syndicated, because even if you do, the money is so lousy that it’s hardly worth the frustration.
Continue reading

Witnessed at lunch today

Not as surreal as the previous lunch observation, but it was still amusing nonetheless. I love the idea that people are now re-learning elementary-level facts thanks to Jeff Foxworthy.

I wasn’t able to get a good drawing of this group, because I think they figured out I was observing them (even though I could easily hear them from where I was sitting across the dining area) and they took off before I could finish drawing them.

You down with SPP?

I had no idea there was an actual name for it and that it was considered a cartoonist’s convention, but apparently there is – it’s the Silent Penultimate Panel.

Arnold Wagner wrote about it recently on his blog, and that was where my eyes were first opened to it.

I’ve used those now and again (I try not to over-use them, but they’re fun). Frequent cartoon-lunch cohort Matthew Hansen refers to them as “Third Panel Guys Staring at Each Other cartoons,” which has a nice ring to it, but I’m kind of excited to now refer to them as SPPs.

Here’s one of my favorites.

EDIT: And another.